Anyone who has bought software knows the model: you pay per user per month. For the seller it is an attractive way to earn money, because a single platform that thousands of users connect to, each paying every month, produces predictable and growing revenue. The model has spread to business telephony, so a business phone system is now often priced per user.

That the model works for the seller does not mean it suits telephony. In this article we explain why telephony fits poorly into a price per user, and why we charge per plan, with calls included under fair use. What each plan costs is on our pricing page.

For software, a price per user makes sense, because every user has their own account, their own data and their own licence. For the seller, revenue grows automatically with every business that grows, without extra cost behind it. That makes it one of the most profitable models there is.

Now imagine your broadband was billed per device in the building, so a new printer or an extra laptop in the office pushed up your contract. Or that your electricity supplier charged per person working in the building rather than for the power you use. Nobody would find that logical, because the cost of such a service does not come from the number of people or devices but from the use. Telephony works the same way.

How business phone systems used to be sold

A phone system was always sold per system and per number of available lines. The number of lines decided how many calls could take place at the same time, and that is what you paid for. Nobody came round to count how many handsets were in a building, because it made no difference to the cost.

That logic still holds. Whether five or fifteen handsets hang off a number, the number of calls coming in does not change. What does change is the number of minutes, and that is exactly where the real cost sits.

What about reception, the kitchen and the colleague who picks up?

A price per user assumes every phone belongs to one person. In an ordinary business that is rarely the case. There is a handset on reception, one in the kitchen, one in the warehouse and one in the meeting room. If the phone rings while someone is walking past, that person simply answers, even though they are not a “user” on the system.

With a price per user you have to make a choice for each of those handsets: pay for a user who is not a person, or leave the handset out and miss calls. With us, shared handsets and logins never count, because they are devices and accounts, not people. The calls that come in on them are simply part of your plan.

Who keeps track of the users?

Large organisations have an IT department that creates accounts and removes them again. Small businesses, such as a GP surgery, a solicitor’s office in Limerick or a trades firm in Galway, usually have no administrator. Someone connects the number today, and when that person moves to another role next year, nobody quite knows who is on the system any more.

In practice a new administrator mostly adds users but rarely removes anyone. Disconnecting feels risky, because who knows whether the main number will still work afterwards. The result is that the number of paid users creeps up unnoticed, while the number of people who actually take calls stays the same. With a price per plan that problem does not arise, because an extra name on the system does not change your monthly bill.

1800 numbers do not fit the model at all

On a Freephone 1800 number your business pays for the call instead of the caller. The cost then depends entirely on how many minutes customers spend calling you, and not at all on how many people answer. A price per user cannot even be attached to it, which shows that the model comes from software rather than from telephony.

A price per user only works if one package is built on one phone system and as many users as possible are placed on one line. That is tidy for the seller, but it means your telephony is set up around a revenue model rather than around the way your business is called.

Networks settle with each other per minute

There is another reason why the user is the wrong unit: phone networks charge each other per minute, not per person. When a call passes from one network to another, the networks charge each other an interconnection rate per minute. That rate is closely regulated, so that networks do not overcharge each other.

That settlement applies to all traffic, inbound and outbound. Even when a customer calls your number, we pay the interconnection charge per minute to the network that customer is calling from, to deliver the call to us, and if you forward to a mobile, we pay the network that delivers the call to you. So every call you receive costs money per minute, however many users are on your system.

In Ireland, ComReg regulates the telecoms market, and CallFactory is registered with ComReg as an operator (ERAU10001358). As an operator with our own interconnection, we work with minutes as the unit ourselves. Because an ordinary business makes relatively few calls, we include those minutes in your plan, within fair use, instead of passing them on per person.

Your plan covers more than the calls alone. It also includes the capacity, meaning the number of lines needed to let calls come in at the same time, and the phone system itself: routing, opening hours, call menus, queues, voicemail and the dashboard. So there is no separate line on your invoice for lines or platform fees.

What a business phone system costs with us: per plan, calls included

On an Irish number, calls are included in your plan with normal use: forwarding to a mobile or landline, calling out with your business number and calls answered over the internet. If a business regularly calls a lot more than that, we charge 10 cent per minute to Irish mobiles and landlines alike, billed per second with no start fee. That 10 cent also covers call recording, transcription and logging of the call, if you want them. If you would rather not depend on fair use, you can choose to pay per minute from the start at the same rate. 1800 numbers, foreign numbers and forwarding to a phone abroad are always delivered over the fixed or mobile network, never over the internet, and have their own per-minute rate, which you get on request.

We do know users, but we group them into plans. Business Number is for one person at €149 a year, Phone System for up to two people at €25 a month and Customer Service for up to eight people at €49 a month, with a call menu, a queue and call recording. Adding or removing a colleague within your plan does not change your monthly bill, and handsets on reception or in the kitchen are free. For more than eight people we put together a custom plan. What fair use means in practice is explained in unlimited calls or pay per minute.

For an ordinary business that means you don’t need to worry about call costs. A team of four that calls normally pays €49 a month with us on Customer Service, with those calls included. At a price of €18 per user, the same team would pay €72 a month, and a team of eight €144.

What if your team makes a lot of calls?

If your team is on the phone a lot, a price per user with unlimited calling is not the answer either, because a fair use policy usually applies there too. With us you then pay 10 cent per minute to Irish mobiles and landlines, or you choose from the start to pay per minute. That 10 cent also covers call recording, transcription and logging of the call, if you want them. You pay for exactly what is called, and you don’t depend on fair use.

Either way you keep the benefits of a plan: calls can be delivered over the fixed and mobile networks, the phone still rings if the internet goes down, and you don’t have to keep track of users. A number takes up to 50 team members and 50 simultaneous calls, so a busy customer service team fits on one number.